Meyer-Optik Gorlitz Primoplan 58mm f/1.9 II

Leica M-Mount

Review

The Meyer-Optik Gorlitz Primoplan 58mm f/1.9 II is a remarkable lens that transports photographers back to a time when character was often prioritized over clinical perfection in optics. Designed for the Leica M mount, this lens not only inherits the vintage charm associated with Meyer-Optik but also delivers impressive performance that appeals to a diverse range of shooting styles, from portraiture to street photography.

One of the standout features of the Primoplan 58mm is its fast maximum aperture of f/1.9, which allows for excellent low-light capabilities and beautiful shallow depth of field. Photographers will appreciate how this lens can create stunning bokeh, particularly in portrait work, where the background smoothly melts away, highlighting the subject. The optical design is optimized to produce a sense of three-dimensionality and a unique glow to the images, contributing to a distinct rendering that many find visually compelling.

Sharpness is commendable, especially at smaller apertures. While wide open at f/1.9, the lens exhibits a certain softness that may not suit everyone’s taste, but this can be an asset for those looking to achieve a dreamy aesthetic. As you stop down, sharpness improves significantly, providing crisp and detailed images ideal for general use. The lens exhibits minimal distortion and chromatic aberration, making it a reliable choice for everyday photography.

The build quality of the Primoplan 58mm f/1.9 II is another noteworthy aspect. Constructed with a solid metal chassis, it feels robust and durable in hand. The focus ring is smooth and well-dampened, allowing for precise manual focusing, which is a must for Leica M users accustomed to a tactile shooting experience.

However, its manual focus nature may pose challenges for some photographers, especially in fast-paced shooting situations. Additionally, at times the lens may flare under direct sunlight, which, while it can be artistically beneficial, might be viewed negatively by those who prefer more control over such effects.

Pros and Cons

Pros

• Fast maximum aperture of f/1.9 for excellent low-light performance and shallow depth of field.
• Unique bokeh and characterful rendering that enhances portrait photographs.
• Solid metal build quality with a smooth focus ring for precise control.
• Minimal distortion and chromatic aberration for clean images.

Cons

• Softness at f/1.9 may not appeal to those seeking sharpness immediately.
• Manual focus may not suit everyone, particularly in dynamic settings.
• Potential for lens flare when shooting against bright light sources.

Verdict

The Meyer-Optik Gorlitz Primoplan 58mm f/1.9 II is an enchanting lens that bridges the gap between classic design and modern photography needs. Ideal for photographers seeking creativity over technical perfection, it offers a unique blend of beautiful bokeh, vintage charm, and solid handling. While it may not be the sharpest lens wide open, the character it imparts is often worth the trade-off. If you appreciate a touch of nostalgia in your images and enjoy the art of manual focusing, this lens could very well find a cherished place in your collection.